Is this Kerry's first Arctic Redpoll?

Perhaps an Arctic Redpoll? Lough Gill, 6th November 2021 (Michael O'Clery).

I took the short walk around the back of the clubhouse at Castlegregory Golf Club to view the lake, but after just a short distance, a bird flushed from a reed stem just feet in front of me. My immediate thought was "What the hell is a Wheatear doing in a reedbed?", such was the overall greyness of the plumage and sparkling white rump of the bird now flying low away from me. A quick look in the bins as it landed just 20 feet away on another reed stem and I was in shock. It was a Redpoll, but so pale, and lacking in any warm tones, that alarm bells rang.

I tried to put the 'scope down gently, grabbed the camera, pointed, shot off a few point blank frames when... feck... the lens cap was on and the camera was off. Instead of full-frame glorious photos, I had to scramble to get the camera sorted. The Redpoll was oblivious to my quietly frantic activity, but flew slightly further along the track. I managed these three photos, here, cropped, but otherwise unedited. Then the bird took off over my head towards the large earth embankment by the clubhouse.

The best of the three photos, showing most of the features of an Arctic Redpoll, Lough Gill, 6th November 2021 (Michael O'Clery).

I went straight there and had just laid eyes on it again - this time with 5-6 Linnets - when they all took off. The Redpoll circled a while, separated from the Linnets, and headed out of view, seeming to drop somewhere in the reeds nearby. That was it. Despite looking for days after. I put bird seed along the track and on the embankment in the hope of drawing it back. Didn't work. Gone. Frustratingly brief.

So, what was it? The paleness was striking. The white-looking rump also, so striking, and the photos showed a few other features I didn't get to see through the bins.

So is it an Arctic Redpoll? Lough Gill, 6th November 2021 (Michael O'Clery).

The jury is out. Still trying to figure out is there enough info in these three photos to claim it as an Arctic Redpoll. Perhaps not, but if the experts do come back with confirmation, the champagne corks will fly. We'll see.

Photographer Nerd Extra: With the suddenness of the birds appearance and the rapidity with which I tried, clumsily, to get the camera to bear, it was only later that I was able to gauge the camera settings on those three photos. Was the exposure way up, making it look paler that it actually was? Here's a screengrab of the levels (they were actually pretty good, and the EXIF info, showing it was 1/3 over-exposed. Not a lot. The paleness was real, and not a photo effect. Bit of a relief, seeing as my eyes were telling me that already.